How do we score electricity and solar companies?
We score electricity companies and solar companies with two public 100-point formulas. We don’t score or rank roofers or other home-service companies. Ohio and New Jersey electricity suppliers get a checklist, not a score. Scores are our opinions, based on public records and one published method.
What do you need right now? Electricity formula · Pennsylvania · Ohio and New Jersey · Solar formula · Report a score error
How we earn is on How we make money. You never pay us. No partner button sits on this page.
Built on public data from the Public Utility Commission of Texas, Power to Choose, the U.S. Energy Information Administration, state attorneys general, courts, the Better Business Bureau, NABCEP, state licensing boards, Pennsylvania’s Public Utility Commission, PA Power Switch, the Illinois Commerce Commission, and each company’s own contracts and warranties. Page text updated November 10, 2026.
The Day Company is not affiliated with or endorsed by the agencies or companies named as sources. Who we are is on About.
Scores are our opinions, based on public records and one published method, not a statement of fact about any company. Software reads the figures from public sources, and no person reviews each change, so a score or price can be late, incomplete or wrong. Always check the plan’s own documents before you sign up. Found an error? Tell us on our Corrections page. Our Terms of Service apply.
The point tables keep the legal terms the formula needs. Each hard term is explained in “What do these terms mean?”
How is every score made?
Four steps, the same for every scored company. No step is a payment, a sales call or a star rating.
Gather the records
State complaint ratings, fines, court cases, BBB grades and the company’s own contracts and warranties.
Apply one formula
The same steps for every company, and the same point rules for every company scored under one formula.
Show the proof
Each review lists every point earned or lost and links the record behind it. When there is no record, the review says the points were given by default.
Re-check and log
When a new record turns up, we re-score and date the change in the review’s changelog.
Roofing is not scored.
What do the bands mean?
| Score | Rating |
|---|---|
| 90–100 | Excellent |
| 80–89 | Very good |
| 70–79 | Good |
| 60–69 | Fair |
| Under 60 | Poor |
The same bands are used for electricity companies and solar companies. Roofing is not scored.
What do the 100 points measure for an electricity company in Texas?
Six categories. Many records come from the Public Utility Commission of Texas (PUCT).
| Category | Points | What it measures | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Complaints to the state | 25 | How often customers complain, adjusted for how big the company is | PUCT complaint scorecard |
| Fines and penalties | 20 | State penalties and settlements in the last 10 years, by size | PUCT orders, Texas Attorney General |
| Contract fairness | 20 | Cancel fee, arbitration, extra fees, a plain plan and the free-cancel window | Terms of service, fact labels |
| Price | 20 | The simplest 12-month fixed plan at 1,000 kWh vs the Texas average | Electricity Facts Labels, EIA |
| Time in business | 10 | Years licensed, plus bill help and audited financials | PUCT license, company filings |
| BBB rating | 5 | The letter grade on the Texas retail-electricity profile | Better Business Bureau |
Add the six for a score out of 100.
How are Texas complaints scored?
The PUCT rates every active provider on complaints per 1,000 customers over the last six months. It sorts providers into five groups of about the same size. Five circles means the fewest complaints. We use this rating, not the raw count.
| PUCT scorecard rating | Points |
|---|---|
| 5 of 5, the lowest complaint rate | 25 |
| 4 of 5 | 20 |
| 3 of 5 | 15 |
| 2 of 5 | 10 |
| 1 of 5, the highest complaint rate | 5 |
| Not on the scorecard | 15, and we say so |
The scorecard counts every informal complaint the PUCT investigated, whether or not the company was at fault. Each review names the release it used. Raw complaint counts may show on the review. They do not change the score.
How does the BBB grade count for an electricity company?
Only the letter counts. Customer reviews and BBB accreditation do not move the score.
| BBB letter grade | Points |
|---|---|
| A+ or A | 5 |
| A− | 4 |
| B+, B or B− | 3 |
| C+, C or C− | 2 |
| D+, D or D− | 1 |
| F | 0 |
| No rating or no profile | 2, and we say so |
Source: the BBB profile for the Texas retail electricity company.
How do Texas fines count?
A company starts with all 20 points. It loses points for each state penalty in the last 10 years. Points stop at zero.
| Each penalty or settlement (last 10 years) | Points off |
|---|---|
| Under $100,000 | 4 |
| $100,000 to $499,999 | 8 |
| $500,000 or more | 12 |
Counts PUCT penalties and Texas Attorney General judgments or settlements. A penalty shared with other companies, with no separate amount for each, counts in full against each company named. We search every name a company uses. When a penalty is about to pass the 10-year mark, the review says when the score will change. Penalties against a parent company’s power plants or wholesale trading do not count. The review still mentions them.
These dollar bands are the scoring rule. They are not a price a partner pays us.
How is the Texas contract scored?
Five sub-rules. They add up to 20.
| Sub-rule | Max | How we score it |
|---|---|---|
| Early-cancel fee | 5 | On the simplest 12-month plan: $150 or less = 5. $151 to $200 = 3. $201 to $300 = 1. Over $300 = 0. Fee not posted = 0. If the fee is charged per month left, we score the most you could owe. |
| No forced arbitration | 4 | No arbitration clause and no class-action waiver = 4. One of them = 2. Both = 0. |
| Extra fees | 4 | 4 minus the number of company fees beyond early cancellation, late payment and returned payment. Floor 0. Refundable deposits, third-party payment-center fees, utility charges passed through at cost, and collection costs with no set amount do not count. |
| A simple fixed plan | 4 | At least one 12-month plan with one energy rate and no bill credits, usage tiers or time-of-use pricing. A flat monthly charge is allowed. |
| Free-cancel window | 3 | Beyond the legal 3 business days: 30 or more days = 3. 7 to 29 days = 2. 4 to 6 days = 1. Under 4 days, or none = 0. Counts only if the scored plan’s fact label or the terms grant it. |
An arbitration clause sends disputes to a private arbitrator instead of a court. A class-action waiver stops customers from suing together. Texas rules already let you cancel a new plan within 3 business days of getting its terms, so only extra days earn points.
How is Texas price scored?
We take the company’s simplest 12-month fixed plan (for battery companies, the plan that comes with the battery; see battery companies). We average its Electricity Facts Label price at 1,000 kWh in Dallas (ZIP 75201) and Houston (ZIP 77002), then compare that with the Texas average.
Write the plan’s average price as a percent of that average, rounded to a whole percent. Then: Points = 20 − (percent − 90) / 2.
Round to the nearest point, with halves rounding down, and keep the result between 0 and 20. A plan at 90% of the average or below earns 20. A plan at 129% or more earns 0. A plan at 95% works out to 17.5, which rounds down to 17.
The Texas average is the residential price in EIA Electric Power Monthly, Table 5.6.A. For the current reviews that figure is 15.88¢ per kWh (July 2026). Each review states the month it used.
If one city has no 12-month fixed plan from that company, we score the other city alone and say so.
If there is no simple 12-month plan, we still score the simplest 12-month fixed plan, even if it has a bill credit or an add-on, and say so. That company also misses the 4 contract points for a simple fixed plan.
| Plan price vs Texas average | Points |
|---|---|
| 90% or less | 20 |
| 98% | 16 |
| 106% | 12 |
| 120% | 5 |
| 129% or more | 0 |
Prices on a review come from the Electricity Facts Label and include delivery, not taxes.
How does time in business count for an electricity company?
Years since the Texas retail license, plus two add-ons.
| Measure | Points |
|---|---|
| Licensed 20 or more years | 6 |
| Licensed 10 to 19 years | 4 |
| Licensed 5 to 9 years | 2 |
| Licensed under 5 years | 0 |
| Runs or funds a bill-help program | +2 |
| It or its parent publishes audited financials | +2 |
Years count from the PUCT “Date Licensed.” A bill-help program counts when the company’s own terms say it runs or funds one.
What does each score rest on?
| Label | What it means |
|---|---|
| ● Record found | The points come from a public record we found and read. |
| ◐ Searched, none found | We searched and found nothing, for example no state fines. The points are earned by that result. |
| ○ Default points, no record | The information does not exist. A fixed number of points is given by default. This is not a finding about the company. |
| ◑ Partly default points | Some of the category was read and some was not. |
| ✕ No data, no points | There was nothing to score, so no points were given. |
Each label is words and a symbol, not color alone. The labels do not change points. A score is not a pure measure of complaints or legal history, because price is one of the categories. Where a complaint rate cannot be worked out, the page says “Complaint rate unavailable” and names the missing half. “Fewer than 5 state complaints” is a real result, and a good one.
What does an electricity score look like?
This company is made up, to show how the formula works.
Example Energy Co.: 65/100, Fair
| Category | Score | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Complaints | 15/25 | PUCT scorecard 3 of 5 |
| BBB rating | 3/5 | B |
| Fines and penalties | 12/20 | Two penalties under $100,000 (−4 −4) |
| Contract fairness | 11/20 | Cancel fee 5, arbitration 0, extra fees 2, plain plan 4, window 0 |
| Price | 16/20 | Plan price = 98% of the Texas average |
| Time in business | 8/10 | 20 or more years (6) + bill help (2); no audited financials (0) |
| Total | 65/100 | 15 + 3 + 12 + 11 + 16 + 8 |
Every review shows its own breakdown using this formula. See our company reviews.
How do we score battery companies?
A battery company sells you power and puts a battery at your home. We give it two scores. Both use the same six rows and 100 points as every electricity company.
| Score | What it judges | Where it shows |
|---|---|---|
| Battery deal score | The power contract and the battery agreement together | The score ring, the page title and, in Texas, the rankings |
| Power plan score | The power contract alone | The review page and the battery comparison page, not the rankings |
In both scores, the price row uses the power plan that comes with the battery, not the simplest 12-month plan, because that is the plan you sign up for with the battery. In Texas, that is the battery plan’s price at 1,000 kWh, from its fact label or, when it posts none, its posted prices. In Illinois, the price row compares the on-peak price with ComEd’s price to compare, frozen like the Texas average. The other five rows use Illinois records and the Texas points, except as noted here: complaints come from the Illinois Commerce Commission complaint summary (opens in a new tab) (no Illinois battery company we score has a record there yet, so each earns 15 of 25 by default, and the review says so), fines are state penalties in the last 10 years, and time in business counts years licensed in Illinois (when the license date is not on the record, the review says so and counts from the month the company began selling in Illinois). In the power plan score, the cancel window counts only days beyond the 10 days Illinois law already gives (in the battery agreement score, as in Texas, it counts days beyond the legal 3). Illinois battery offers get both scores, but they are not ranked in any table.
No complaint record? A company that is not on the state complaint list, in Texas or in Illinois, gets 15 of 25 complaint points by default, and the review says so. We score it again when a new state list includes it.
How do we score Pennsylvania electric suppliers?
Same 100 points and the same six parts. Pennsylvania keeps its own records. Suppliers sell the power part of the bill. We compare their price with the utility’s price to compare, not with the Texas average.
| Category | Points | What it measures | Where the number comes from |
|---|---|---|---|
| Complaints to the state | 25 | Complaints adjusted for how many homes the supplier serves | PA PUC 2024 UCARE report, EIA Form EIA-861 |
| Fines and penalties | 20 | State penalties and settlements in the last 10 years, by size | PA PUC orders, Pennsylvania Attorney General |
| Contract fairness | 20 | Cancel fee, arbitration, extra fees, a plain plan and the free-cancel window | Terms of service, PA Power Switch offer details |
| Price | 20 | The simplest 12-month fixed plan at 1,000 kWh vs the utility’s price to compare | PA Power Switch |
| Time in business | 10 | Years licensed, plus bill help and audited financials | PA PUC supplier license, company filings |
| BBB rating | 5 | The letter grade on the BBB profile | Better Business Bureau |
Complaints. Pennsylvania does not publish a 5-circle rating. We use the PUC’s 2024 UCARE report (opens in a new tab), published in April 2026, and EIA Form EIA-861 for 2024 homes served. Complaints divided by homes, times 10,000.
| Complaints per 10,000 homes | Points |
|---|---|
| Under 5 | 25 |
| 5 to under 10 | 20 |
| 10 to under 17 | 15 |
| 17 to under 27 | 10 |
| 27 or more | 5 |
The PUC lists some suppliers only as having “fewer than five” complaints. A supplier with 8,317 homes or more earns 25: at that size, even 4 complaints are under 5 per 10,000. A smaller one earns 15, because there are too few complaints to rate fairly. A supplier with no home count, or not in the state’s 2024 complaint report, also earns 15. We say so each time. The cutoffs split the suppliers that have both numbers and at least 1,000 homes into five groups of about the same size, then round. The PUC says its counts are not adjusted for size and are not findings of wrongdoing.
Other categories.
| Category | Max | How we score it |
|---|---|---|
| BBB rating | 5 | Same letters and points as Texas. No rating or no profile = 2, and we say so. Read date for the grades: October 16, 2026. |
| Fines and penalties | 20 | Start at 20. Under $100,000 = 4 off. $100,000 to $499,999 = 8 off. $500,000 or more = 12 off. Floor 0. A shared penalty counts in full for each company named. Actions in other states are shown and not scored. |
| Contract fairness | 20 | Same five rules as Texas, with three differences. A plan with no cancel fee earns all 3 window points, because you can leave at any time without a fee. A contract we cannot read earns 2 of the 4 arbitration points, and the review says so. A simple-plan check we cannot make earns 2 of 4, and the review says so. As in Texas, the window counts only days beyond the 3 business days state law already gives you. |
| Time in business | 10 | 20 or more years = 6. 10 to 19 = 4. 5 to 9 = 2. Under 5 = 0. Add 2 for a bill-help program. Add 2 for audited financials. |
Price. We take the simplest fixed 12-month plan in each of two utility areas, PPL and PECO, from PA Power Switch (opens in a new tab). If PA Power Switch lists none, we use the supplier’s own website. We add any monthly fee, spread over 1,000 kWh. A $10 monthly fee adds 1 cent per kWh. That is method math, not a live price. We average the two percents. If a supplier sells in only one area, we use that one and say so.
Same 0 to 20 cap and the same rounding of points as Texas, but we don’t round the percent to a whole number first.
The price to compare is frozen so every supplier is measured on the same yardstick.
When a utility changes its price to compare, our price points do not move until we re-score every supplier together.
In Pennsylvania, price is compared to your utility’s price to compare. Pennsylvania electricity guides
| Supplier price vs price to compare | Points |
|---|---|
| Under 91% | 20 |
| 100%, the same price | 15 |
| 110% | 10 |
| 120% | 5 |
| 129% or more | 0 |
No fixed 12-month plan: we use the simplest posted plan and say so. A teaser of 3 months or less scores 0 for price. So does no home price at all.
Pennsylvania uses the same bands: 90–100 Excellent, 80–89 Very good, 70–79 Good, 60–69 Fair, under 60 Poor.
A partner’s plans stay out of every Pennsylvania table, count, chart and score, and the page says so. A plan finder on our pages is labeled Partner tool. It is not scored. When that tool can pay us is on How we make money.
How do we check Ohio and New Jersey suppliers?
Ohio and New Jersey suppliers get a checklist, not a score. Ohio publishes no complaint counts for each supplier. New Jersey’s quarterly counts do not fit the Pennsylvania formula. We run five checks and mark Pass, Watch or Fail, with the source and the day we read it.
| Check | Pass | Watch | Fail |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Licensed to sell to homes here | Listed for homes: on the Energy Choice Ohio residential chart, or on the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities (BPU) active license list and NJ Power Switch | None | Not listed. We do not build a page |
| 2. BBB record | A− or better, and BBB accredited | B+ to C−, or not accredited | D+ to F |
| 3. Contract terms | A fixed price for the whole term, and an early cancel fee of $100 or less, or none | A price that changes, a fee over $100, or a plan that renews to a variable price | The terms are not published |
| 4. Price against the price to compare | Its lowest current fixed offer is at or below the price to compare in at least half of the utility areas where it sells | Within 10% above the price to compare in at least half of those areas | Neither. We list each area |
| 5. State record | No state order or settlement found in the last five years | None | One or more. We name it and link the order |
The BBB row also shows the number of complaints BBB lists for the last three years. More than one BBB listing: we use the headquarters profile and mention the others. Check 4 compares the lowest current fixed residential offer with the price to compare in each utility area. On Ohio pages the price row reads the Ohio price robot’s files, so the figures and the Pass, Watch or Fail follow the latest chart. The date shows as “Prices refreshed.” Without JavaScript, the row shows the figures from when the page was built. This page does not type those Ohio prices.
“Not published” and “Not checked” are not a Pass and not a Fail. New Jersey shows no supplier prices, so check 4 can read “Not published.”
Complaints: New Jersey shows the BPU’s quarterly counts for the latest four quarters, as information only. Ohio’s page says Ohio does not publish complaints for each supplier.
We re-check every supplier at least every 45 days.
If a supplier becomes our partner, it leaves our ratings, and its page keeps its last independent check and the date.
How are partners kept out of scores?
Partners are never scored. If a company we rate becomes a partner, it leaves our ratings. Its page keeps its last independent score and the date.
We do not take payment to change a score, a rank, the order of our rankings, or what we write about a company. Paid links and partner tools are always labeled as paid. What a partner can pay for is on How we make money.
How are solar companies scored?
Solar companies have their own 100-point formula. It leans on the legal record, the written warranties, honest prices and who puts the system on the roof. Customer star ratings, ads and search rankings do not count. Roofing is not scored.
| Category | Points | What it measures | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Complaints, lawsuits and state actions | 30 | Government actions and class actions over how solar was sold, anywhere in the U.S. in the last 5 years, plus any BBB complaint-pattern alert | State attorneys general, courts, BBB |
| Contract and warranty terms | 25 | Workmanship, roof-leak and equipment warranties, the production guarantee, warranty backup, and court claims about fees or contracts | Warranty documents, contracts, court records |
| Price transparency | 15 | Published prices, loan and dealer fees shown up front, tax-credit claims that match current law | The company’s price pages |
| Who installs | 12 | The company’s own crews, or partner companies | The company’s own words, quoted and linked |
| Time in business | 7 | Years since the company says it was founded | The company’s pages; state filings, labeled as such |
| Certifications | 6 | An active NABCEP-certified person, and installer certifications from equipment makers | NABCEP, equipment makers |
| BBB rating | 5 | The company’s BBB letter grade | Better Business Bureau |
One score follows the company to every state we cover. A company gets a score only when every category is checked. The bands are the table above.
How do solar legal matters count?
Start at 30. Floor at 0. Last 5 years, anywhere in the U.S., against the company or a brand it owns now.
| Each matter | Points off |
|---|---|
| Lawsuit, settlement or consent order from a government agency | 10 |
| Class action over how solar was sold, pending or settled | 10 |
| Investigation demand alone, with no lawsuit | 5 |
| BBB complaint-pattern alert | 8 |
When an investigation leads to a lawsuit, only the lawsuit counts. A lawsuit is an allegation. An investigation demand is a request for records, not a finding. Matters that are not about selling solar to homeowners, and matters from before a company bought a brand when it did not take on that brand’s past claims, are shown and not scored.
How do solar contract and warranty terms count?
| Sub-rule | Max | How we score it |
|---|---|---|
| Workmanship warranty | 7 | In writing: 10 years or more = 7. 5 to 9 = 5. 2 to 4 = 3. Under 2 years or none = 0. |
| Production guarantee | 4 | The company’s own written promise of how much electricity the system will make. A panel maker’s output warranty does not count. |
| Equipment warranties | 4 | The makers’ panel, inverter and battery warranties, in writing. |
| No fee or contract claims in court | 4 | Lost if a counted case involved contract prices or fees. |
| Roof-leak warranty | 3 | In writing, for leaks where the system attaches: 10 years or more = 3. 5 to 9 = 2. 1 to 4 = 1. None = 0. |
| Warranty backup | 3 | The papers say the workmanship warranty is insured or backed by a third party. A company’s own promise alone does not count. |
A current written document earns full points. An older document, or one limited to another state, earns half, rounded down.
A workmanship warranty is the company’s promise to fix problems caused by its own installation work. A production guarantee is a written promise that the system will make a set amount of electricity.
How does solar price transparency count?
| Sub-rule | Max | How we score it |
|---|---|---|
| Its own published prices | 6 | Real prices or a price per watt, posted where anyone can read them. Market averages, monthly-payment teasers and prices shown only after you enter an address do not count. |
| Loan and dealer fees shown up front | 5 | Publishes loan terms and fees, or says how dealer fees are built into the price. |
| Tax-credit claims match current law | 4 | No current page tells homeowners who buy that they can still get the 30% federal credit, which ended after 2025, or builds that credit into prices. Old, dated blog posts do not count against it. |
How does “who installs” count?
| What the company’s own words show | Points |
|---|---|
| Its own crews. It says it does the installs and does not say partners do | 12 |
| Mixed. Its own words say partner companies install in some places | 6 |
| Partner installers or dealers only | 0 |
| Not stated | 0 |
Every review quotes the company’s own words, 10 words or fewer, and links the page.
This category is about solar companies we score. It is not a roofing rank. Roofing is not scored.
How does solar time in business count?
| Years in business | Points |
|---|---|
| 10 or more | 7 |
| 5 to 9 | 5 |
| 2 to 4 | 3 |
| Under 2 | 0 |
We use the founding year the company states. When we only have a state registration date, the review labels it that way.
How do solar certifications count?
| Certification | Max | How we score it |
|---|---|---|
| NABCEP certification | 4 | At least one active NABCEP PV Installation Professional working for the company, in any state. Sales-only credentials do not count. |
| Equipment-maker certification | 2 | Listed or certified by a panel, inverter or battery maker as an installer. |
How does the solar BBB grade count?
| BBB grade | Points |
|---|---|
| Any A | 5 |
| Any B | 4 |
| Any C | 3 |
| Any D | 2 |
| F | 0 |
| Not rated | 3 |
We score the main or headquarters profile and show any others in the review.
Do licenses earn points?
No. A license is required, not a bonus. A company is ranked in a state only if it holds an active electrical contractor license there, or a seller registration and installers who hold the state license. Licenses do not change the score. They decide where a company can be ranked. Every review links the company’s own license list.
Who gets a solar rank?
- One national score per company.
- A state ranking includes only companies with an active electrical contractor license there, or registered sellers that use installers who hold the state license.
- Companies that are bankrupt, closed or appear closed are not ranked. We still score them.
- Ties share a rank.
We call a company national when its own website says it sells home solar in more than 5 states. Companies in 2 to 5 states are regional. One state is labeled with that state.
What do we show and not score?
Customer star ratings, raw BBB complaint counts, how often a company answers, products, payment options and how many states it serves. Those can sit on the review for context. They do not move the score.
What does a solar score look like?
This company is made up, to show how the formula works.
Example Solar Co.: 77/100, Good
| Category | Score | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Complaints, lawsuits and state actions | 20/30 | One class action over how solar was sold, settled (−10) |
| Contract and warranty terms | 22/25 | 10-year workmanship (7), production guarantee (4), equipment warranties (4), no fee or contract claims (4), 10-year roof-leak (3); no warranty backup (0) |
| Price transparency | 10/15 | Published prices (6), honest tax-credit claims (4); no up-front loan fees (0) |
| Who installs | 12/12 | Its own crews |
| Time in business | 5/7 | 5 to 9 years |
| Certifications | 4/6 | NABCEP-certified installer (4); no equipment-maker certification (0) |
| BBB rating | 4/5 | Any B |
| Total | 77/100 | 20 + 22 + 10 + 12 + 5 + 4 + 4 |
A lawsuit is an allegation. Each review links the case.
Every review shows its own breakdown using this formula. See our company reviews.
Can you score a company yourself?
Yes. The tool uses the Texas electricity formula and the solar formula from this page. It does not cover Pennsylvania, the Ohio and New Jersey checklist, or battery companies, whose price row uses the battery plan. It does not save what you enter. It is a self-check, not one of our published scores.
Half credit still applies when solar terms appear only in an older document or one limited to another state.
of 100
of 100
Why is a score an opinion you can still check?
Scores are our opinions, based on public records and one published method.
We do not take payment to change a score, a rank, the order of our rankings, or what we write about a company. Paid links and partner tools are always labeled as paid. What money can buy is on How we make money.
Texas and Pennsylvania electricity companies use the same six categories. The price source is different, as the Pennsylvania section says. Illinois battery companies use them too, with Illinois records, and are not ranked. Ohio and New Jersey suppliers get a checklist, not a score. Solar companies use the seven categories on this page.
How numbers update on their own is on Editorial standards. AI does not write a score.
What do we check that others skip?
Every name
Brand, legal name and every other name on the license.
Owners named
Each review names the parent and the sister brands, so you know when two brands that look different are really one company.
Score changes flagged
When a penalty is about to age out, or a new state rating is due, the review says when the score could change.
Primary sources only
State, utilities, courts, consumer watchdogs and the company’s own documents. Not sites that are paid when you sign up.
Investigations are not verdicts
We report them, take 5 points off for a solar investigation demand, and say it is not proof.
Fixed in the open
Use the Corrections page, or email info@theday.company with “Correction” in the subject.
Think a score is wrong?
Use the Corrections page, or email info@theday.company with “Correction” in the subject. Include the review, the figure and a primary source. What happens next, and how a correction differs from an update, is on Corrections.
If a fix changes a score, we run the score again and log that too. We do not take payment to change a score, a rank, the order of our rankings, or what we write about a company. Paid links and partner tools are always labeled as paid.
Questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
Do companies pay to be scored or ranked?
We do not take payment to change a score, a rank, the order of our rankings, or what we write about a company. Paid links and partner tools are always labeled as paid. Partners are never scored. What a partner can pay for is on How we make money.
What does an electricity company’s score measure?
Texas and Pennsylvania use six categories: complaints (25), contract (20), fines (20), price (20), time in business (10) and the BBB grade (5). Texas price is the simplest 12-month plan (for battery companies, the plan that comes with the battery) against the Texas residential average. Pennsylvania price is the simplest 12-month plan against that utility’s price to compare. Illinois battery companies use the same six categories with Illinois records and are not ranked in any table. Ohio and New Jersey suppliers get a checklist, not a score.
Why the PUCT scorecard instead of the raw count?
A bigger company gets more complaints. The scorecard uses complaints per 1,000 customers over six months and five groups of about the same size.
How does a BBB letter become points?
Electricity: A+ or A = 5, A− = 4, any B = 3, any C = 2, any D = 1, F = 0, no rating = 2. Solar: any A = 5, any B = 4, any C = 3, any D = 2, F = 0, not rated = 3.
What counts as a fine?
For Texas, a PUCT penalty or a Texas Attorney General judgment or settlement in the last 10 years. We subtract 4, 8 or 12 points by size, down to 0. Pennsylvania uses Pennsylvania PUC and Pennsylvania Attorney General records, with the same size bands.
How is price scored?
Texas: average the simplest 12-month fixed plan at 1,000 kWh in Dallas and Houston, or one city alone if the other has no such plan, against EIA Table 5.6.A. Battery companies use the plan that comes with the battery. For the current reviews the average is 15.88¢ per kWh (July 2026). Pennsylvania: against the utility’s price to compare. Illinois battery companies: the on-peak price against ComEd’s frozen price to compare. The formula is Points = 20 − (percent − 90) / 2. Texas and Illinois round the percent to a whole number first, and Pennsylvania does not.
How often do you re-score?
Our system is set to re-check electricity plan prices every 35 days or sooner. We re-score when a new complaint scorecard, a new penalty or a BBB grade change shows up. Solar scores change when a review update finds a new record. Ohio and New Jersey checks are at least every 45 days. How automatic updates work is on Editorial standards.
Does a high score mean the cheapest plan for my home?
No. Price is 20 of 100 points, on one simple plan. Your ZIP code and your use decide the plan. Read the current fact label or price to compare before you sign.
How are solar companies scored?
Legal record 30, contract and warranty 25, price transparency 15, who installs 12, time in business 7, certifications 6, BBB 5.
What if a solar company does not publish prices?
It loses the 6 points for published prices. It can still earn the 5 for fees shown up front and the 4 for tax-credit claims that match current law. We do not guess a price.
Does an open investigation hurt?
For solar, an investigation demand alone is 5 points off. A government lawsuit, settlement or consent order, or a class action over how solar was sold, is 10. For electricity companies, only finished penalties, judgments and settlements count.
Do you score roofers?
No. Roofing is not scored. We don’t score or rank roofers or other home-service companies.
Is a solar score the same in every state we cover?
Yes. One score, in every state we cover. Licenses decide where the company is ranked, not the points.
Can a company get its score changed?
Only with a record. Use the Corrections page, or email info@theday.company with “Correction” in the subject. We do not take payment to change a score, a rank, the order of our rankings, or what we write about a company. Paid links and partner tools are always labeled as paid. What a partner can pay for is on How we make money.
What do these terms mean?
- PUCT
- The Texas agency that licenses electricity companies, handles complaints and fines companies that break its rules.
- Power to Choose
- The PUCT site for comparing plans where Texas lets you choose.
- Electricity Facts Label
- The one-page sheet that shows price at 500, 1,000 and 2,000 kWh, plus length and fees.
- kWh
- The unit electricity is billed in.
- Bill credit
- A discount that applies only if use hits a set level.
- Time-of-use plan
- A price that changes by time of day.
- Early-cancellation fee
- What you pay if you leave before the contract ends.
- Arbitration clause
- Disputes go to a private arbitrator instead of a court.
- Class-action waiver
- Customers cannot join one lawsuit together.
- Class action
- One lawsuit for a group. Claims are allegations until a court rules.
- Consent order
- An agreement, often with no admission of wrongdoing.
- Civil investigative demand
- An order to hand over records. Not a finding.
- BBB complaint-pattern alert
- A notice that the same kind of complaint keeps showing up.
- Workmanship warranty
- A promise to fix problems caused by the company’s own installation work.
- Production guarantee
- A written promise that the system will make a set amount of electricity.
- Roof-leak warranty
- A written promise to fix leaks where the system attaches to the roof.
- Warranty backup
- Insurance or a third party that keeps a workmanship warranty paying if the company closes.
- Price per watt
- System price divided by size in watts.
- TDLR
- The Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation.
- NABCEP
- The North American Board of Certified Energy Practitioners. It certifies people who pass its exams. It is not a state license.
- Price to compare
- The utility price you pay for the power part of the bill if you do not switch. Pennsylvania scores, Illinois battery scores (against ComEd’s frozen price) and the Ohio and New Jersey checks use it. Texas electricity scores use the statewide average instead.
Sources
Show all 19 sources
- PUCT Retail Electric Provider Complaint Scorecard (opens in a new tab). Each review names the release it used.
- PUCT Customer Complaint Statistics (opens in a new tab).
- Power to Choose (opens in a new tab), Electricity Facts Labels.
- U.S. EIA, Electric Power Monthly, Table 5.6.A (opens in a new tab). 15.88¢ per kWh. July 2026.
- PUCT enforcement orders and retail-license records (opens in a new tab).
- Texas Attorney General (opens in a new tab).
- Better Business Bureau (opens in a new tab).
- NABCEP (opens in a new tab).
- Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation, license search (opens in a new tab).
- IRS, residential clean energy credit (opens in a new tab), which ended after 2025.
- SEC EDGAR (opens in a new tab).
- Pennsylvania PUC, 2024 UCARE report (opens in a new tab), published April 2026.
- EIA Form EIA-861 (opens in a new tab), Pennsylvania homes served, 2024.
- PA Power Switch (opens in a new tab).
- Company contracts and Electricity Facts Labels.
- Pennsylvania PUC licensed suppliers and enforcement orders (opens in a new tab).
- Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General (opens in a new tab).
- Energy Choice Ohio residential chart (opens in a new tab), New Jersey BPU active license list (opens in a new tab) and NJ Power Switch (opens in a new tab), for the checklist states.
- Illinois Commerce Commission, retail electric suppliers complaint summary (opens in a new tab).
Each review also links that company’s own terms, fact labels, warranties and the court records behind its score.
How to cite this page: The Day Company review team, “How We Score Electric & Solar Companies,” The Day Company, updated November 10, 2026, https://theday.company/how-we-score.
Changelog · 11 updates, newest November 10, 2026
- November 10, 2026: Said the score-it-yourself tool covers the Texas electricity formula and the solar formula, not Pennsylvania or the Ohio and New Jersey checklist. Put the price formula in the Texas price section and said Texas rounds the percent first and Pennsylvania does not. The battery row now names no company, the Illinois price row says the utility's price to compare, and the price chart reaches 0 at 129 percent. Pennsylvania now lists its three contract differences (no cancel fee earns all 3 window points, an unreadable contract earns 2 of 4 arbitration points, and an unchecked simple plan earns 2 of 4), the Illinois battery rows are spelled out, Illinois battery offers are not ranked in any table, and the price answer says Illinois rounds like Texas. The answers on categories and price now cover Illinois battery companies, and the Illinois Commerce Commission complaint summary is linked and listed as a source. The “Our automatic checks” note now lives on Editorial standards. The Illinois battery rules now name ComEd’s frozen price to compare, the 10-day Illinois cancel rule for the power plan score, and how a missing license date is handled. A cancel fee that is not posted scores 0.
- November 9, 2026: This page owns the two formulas, the bands, the Ohio and New Jersey checklist, and the rule that roofing is not scored. The short answer no longer says every company gets a score. Pennsylvania price uses the price to compare, not the Texas average. The worked examples now use two made-up companies and name no real company. Pennsylvania prices and the supplier count are no longer typed. The price formula is Points = 20 − (percent − 90) / 2. Pay is one line plus a link. Added how battery companies get two scores, and that a company with no state complaint record gets 15 of 25 complaint points by default in Texas and Illinois.
- November 1, 2026: Added the Ohio and New Jersey supplier check.
- October 26, 2026: Added a short “Our automatic checks” note: robots re-read official sources on a schedule, publish only numbers that pass every check, and leave anything unusual for a person; AI never writes a review, score or verdict on its own; people set every rule.
- October 20, 2026: added how we score Pennsylvania electric suppliers: the same 100 points and six categories, built from Pennsylvania records, with the price part measured against each utility’s price to compare. Added the Pennsylvania sources and two related links. No published score changed.
- October 16, 2026: linked four more electricity company reviews scored with this formula. No published score changed.
- October 16, 2026: linked seven new electricity company reviews scored with this formula. No published score changed.
- October 14, 2026: linked four new electricity company reviews scored with this formula. Reworded one key number so it stays true if we add partner links. No published score changed.
- October 12, 2026: moved to theday.company/how-we-score; the old address forwards here. Updated the solar formula on this page to the version behind every solar score published since October 7, 2026: complaints, lawsuits and state actions (30), contract and warranty terms with roof-leak and warranty-backup rules (25), price transparency (15), who installs (12), time in business (7), certifications (6) and the BBB grade (5). Licenses now decide where a company is ranked instead of adding points. Added a score-it-yourself tool, solar worked examples and charts, and made clear that we do not take payment to change a score, a rank, the order of our rankings, or what we write about a company. Paid links and partner tools are always labeled as paid. No published score changed.
- October 5, 2026: added the solar installer formula (100 points, seven categories); clearer electricity rules for per-month cancel fees, which fees count as extra, plans with no simple 12-month option, bill-help programs, penalty searches under every company name and how a parent company’s penalties are handled; and a new section on the standards every review follows. No published score changed.
- October 4, 2026: page published. The full 100-point public-records formula for electricity providers, with the rating bands and worked examples.
Scores rate companies, not individual plans or solar systems. Each is calculated with the formulas on this page from the public records listed in that review, on the date shown. They are not advice to pick a provider or installer. Plan prices, quotes and terms change, so check the current Electricity Facts Label or contract before you sign.